Human Rights Watch (HRW) has urged France to halt any plans to forcibly return Afghan nationals to Afghanistan, following reports that Paris has begun technical discussions with the Taliban administration on deportation procedures.
Fereshta Abbasi, Afghanistan researcher at Human Rights Watch, said France's confirmation of technical talks with the Taliban regarding the return of Afghan nationals represents a worrying shift in migration policy and could conflict with international human rights obligations.
The French government has said the discussions are aimed at facilitating the removal of Afghan nationals who lack legal residency status or are considered a threat to public security. French officials have described the contacts as limited and technical in nature.
However, Human Rights Watch says France has not publicly provided guarantees regarding the safety of individuals who could face risks upon their return to Afghanistan, particularly women and girls.
Abbasi said documented evidence shows that Taliban authorities have detained and abused some Afghans who were forcibly returned to the country. She also noted that since returning to power in August 2021, the Taliban have imposed sweeping restrictions on women and girls and continued broader crackdowns on fundamental freedoms.
Human Rights Watch called on France to suspend any plans for forced returns, arguing that governments should avoid cooperation on deportations while serious human rights violations persist in Afghanistan.
The warning comes as several European countries explore ways to return certain Afghan nationals whose asylum claims have been rejected or who are considered security risks. Similar discussions on migration cooperation were also raised during contacts between Taliban representatives and European Union officials earlier this year.
Germany has already resumed the return of some Afghan nationals, including individuals convicted of criminal offences.
Human rights organizations argue that forced returns could violate the international principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits sending individuals to countries where they face a real risk of persecution, torture, or other serious harm.
France has not formally recognized the Taliban administration since its return to power in 2021. The ongoing discussions have reignited debate over how European governments can enforce immigration laws while upholding international protection obligations.